RipFacts18+

Courtyard.io vs Arena Club: buyback, payouts and shipping compared

📅 Checked Nov 11, 2026✍ RipFacts team🔍 Not tested hands-on yet💰 How we earn

💬 Straight facts. Every fact shows where it came from. Some links earn us a reward: those sites are tagged đŸ€ Partner and shown first. Their facts are checked exactly like everyone else’s. Details

⚡ Short answer

Both sell graded-only slab packs backed by a vault. Courtyard gives you 7 days to accept a buyback and a marketplace with a 0% seller fee, but pays in USDC and doesn’t publish its shipping fee. Arena Club starts at $25, pays to your bank through Stripe and charges $1 per card to retrieve, but its guaranteed 90% buyback on PokĂ©mon packs lasts only 24 hours.

👀 At a glance

Courtyard.io

Graded slab packs
7/8 facts
🔁BuybackNo % published
đŸ’”Cheapest pack$15
🏩Cash outCrypto (USDC)
📍USNo states excluded
ReviewVisit 18+

Arena Club

Graded slab packs
8/8 facts
🔁Buyback90%
đŸ’”Cheapest pack$25
🏩Cash outTo your bank
📍USNo state list found
🎁 Code FIRSTPACK20: 20% off first pack
ReviewVisit 18+

📊 Side by side

What do the colours mean?
Official on the site’s own pagesReported only other sources say itConflict sources disagreeNot verified not published

How we check facts

FactCourtyard.ioArena Club
Verified facts7/88/8
Company behind itCourtyard Inc., a Delaware corporation OfficialArenaclub.com, Inc. (the seller on its App Store listing; its Terms call it “Arena Club”). Official
What you actually getA professionally graded card (PSA, CGC or BGS) chosen at random from the pack tier, stored in Courtyard’s insured vault and represented in your account (Courtyard NFTs live on Ethereum per the Terms). OfficialEvery PokĂ©mon Slab Pack contains a graded, authenticated card, with no raw pulls. Keep it in the vault (Oregon), ship it, or sell it back. Official
Pack pricesPokémon packs from $15 to $10,000: Basic $15, Starter $25, Pro $50, Master $100, Ultra $250, Platinum $500, Diamond $1,000, Legend $2,500, Mythic $5,000, Cosmic $10,000. OfficialSlab Packs start at $25. Official
Buyback / sell-back termsOptional instant offer at a percentage of the card’s fair market value (FMV), as shown on each product page, open for 7 days. Courtyard sets FMV itself and does not disclose its model. Third-party reviews report ~84.6–90%. OfficialThe PokĂ©mon page advertises a “guaranteed 90% buyback” of the card’s value, valid for 24 hours after the rip. Another official page advertises a “100% card estimated value buyback offer”. Conflict
How you get money outBuyback funds arrive as USDC in your Courtyard wallet/account, usable on the marketplace or for purchases. OfficialWallet withdrawals are processed through Stripe Connect to your linked bank account. Promotional rewards (Tokens, ArenaCash) can’t be withdrawn. Official
Shipping cost & timeYou pay a shipping fee to redeem the physical slab, and ID verification is required. The fee and delivery time are not stated in the docs we read. Not verifiedRetrieving a card from the vault costs $1 per card plus shipping. Official
Odds disclosureEach pack shows a live value distribution before you buy. On November 11, 2026 the $25 Starter Pack showed: 33% chance of a card worth $15–20, 37% $20–25, 28% $25–50, 1% $50–100 and 1% $100–400, with an average item value of $25. OfficialAdvertises “full hit rate transparency”: you can view every possible card in a pack before you buy. A public Hit Feed shows recent pulls. Official
Who can use it (age, states)18+ (or legal age to contract). The Terms exclude sanctioned jurisdictions; no US state exclusions are listed. Official18+ (or the age of majority in your state, if higher). We did not find a list of excluded states. Official
US statesCourtyard’s Terms exclude sanctioned jurisdictions and list no US state exclusions. Official18+. We did not find a list of excluded states in Arena Club’s Terms. Not verified

🔁 Buyback

Courtyard shows a percentage of its own fair market value on each product page and keeps the offer open for 7 days. Arena Club guarantees 90% of the card’s value on PokĂ©mon packs, but only for 24 hours (another of its pages says 100%).

🏩 Getting money out

Arena Club withdraws to your bank through Stripe Connect. Courtyard pays buybacks as USDC into your Courtyard account.

📩 Shipping

Arena Club publishes its retrieval fee: $1 per card plus shipping. Courtyard charges a shipping fee and requires ID verification, but doesn’t publish the amount.

🎯 Which should you pick?

Choose Courtyard.io if

  • You want a full week to decide on a buyback
  • You plan to trade cards on a marketplace with a 0% seller fee
  • You’re comfortable being paid in USDC

Courtyard.io review Visit 18+

Choose Arena Club if

  • You want money sent to your bank
  • You plan to take cards home and want a cheap, published retrieval fee
  • You want to see every possible card in a pack before buying

Code: FIRSTPACK20 (public code)

Arena Club review Visit 18+

More: all comparisons · every Pokémon pack site · buyback rates compared

❓ FAQ

Which has the better buyback, Courtyard.io or Arena Club?

Courtyard shows a percentage of its own fair market value on each product page and keeps the offer open for 7 days. Arena Club guarantees 90% of the card’s value on PokĂ©mon packs, but only for 24 hours (another of its pages says 100%).

Which makes it easier to get money out?

Arena Club withdraws to your bank through Stripe Connect. Courtyard pays buybacks as USDC into your Courtyard account.

Which ships faster or cheaper?

Arena Club publishes its retrieval fee: $1 per card plus shipping. Courtyard charges a shipping fee and requires ID verification, but doesn’t publish the amount.

Are Courtyard.io and Arena Club available in my state?

Courtyard.io: Courtyard’s Terms exclude sanctioned jurisdictions and list no US state exclusions. Arena Club: 18+. We did not find a list of excluded states in Arena Club’s Terms. See availability by state.

Sources

  1. Courtyard Terms of Service (official)
  2. Courtyard blog: Click, rip, repeat (official)
  3. Courtyard: Pokémon Starter Pack page (tiers, prices, value distribution) (official)
  4. courtyard.io homepage (official)
  5. Courtyard Help: Understanding buyback offers (official)
  6. PackSpy: Courtyard review (third party)
  7. App Store: Arena Club (official)
  8. Arena Club Terms of Service (official)
  9. Arena Club Pokémon page (official)
  10. Arena Club slab pack page (official)
  11. Arena Club pricing (official)
  12. Arena Club submit page (official)
  13. Arena Club blog: Hit Feed 101 (official)